Proposed substation connector power line under scrutiny from landowners

Opposition is growing to a proposed power line route in Cypress County that would connect a new wind power project to substations near Medicine Hat.

The Winnifred Wind project would be built north of the County of Forty Mile hamlet, located about 14 kilometres northeast of Bow Island, but the new transmission line is planned to run along a township road in Cypress County then along Highway 3 toward the city.

This week the Alberta Utilities Commission announced a hearing into the route will be held in December to consider the arguments of 12 affected landowners who have registered as intervenors to argue against the route.

They argue in submissions to the AUC that the line route makes it unclear if the line is located on private land or a utility right of way beside the road. Several worry about irrigation pivot operations as well as land values.

The company states in materials published for public consultation that the route comprises a combination of an existing right of way and on new or existing private easements.

Cypress County submitted that it believe a the road right-of-way corridor that already houses telecommunications lines and part of the Westside Water Co-op system is too narrow for the new line.

The county also states it plans to further develop roadway on the 20-metre-wide corridor.

The line, to be known as 498L, would be built from a new substation (“Enerfin Holsom”) along Range Road 84, then Township Road 114 eastward to meet Highway 3 northeast of Seven Persons. It would follow the highway toward Medicine Hat, then jog east to the existing AltaLInk substation (“Bullshead”) near Range Road 63.

Enerfin plans to build a 16 to 22 turbine wind farm south of Rattlesnake Reservoir.

The company plans to begin construction in mid 2022, and have it completed by the end of 2023. That project is not part of the current hearing process.

The AUC hearing process for the grid connection requires intervenors to submit final positions for consideration by Dec. 17.

No date of decision has been set.

Alberta landowners and legal experts criticize well cleanup bill

By Bob Weber The Canadian Press

Posted April 8, 2020 1:34 pm

Updated April 8, 2020 10:52 pm

Landowners and legal experts say Alberta’s hastily passed bill to help clean up the province’s huge stockpile of abandoned energy facilities harms property rights without addressing why the problem exists in the first place.

They say the United Conservative government, which passed the bill in three days in an emergency session last week — despite the fact the problem is decades old, is using the COVID-19 crisis to make legislation without consulting the people it affects.

“This has very little to do with COVID,” said Regan Boychuk of the Alberta Liabilities Disclosure Project, a watchdog group of landowners and policy analysts.

“It wasn’t possible for landowner or opposition politicians to digest or analyze, let alone meaningfully respond, in three days. One has to assume that was the objective.”

Nigel Bankes, a professor of resource law at the University of Calgary, also criticized how quickly the bill became law.

“This was rammed through in a most inappropriate way,” he said.

Alberta Energy spokesman Kavi Bal said the approach was needed in anticipation of even more bankruptcies in the oilpatch caused by a combination of the global pandemic and the recent collapse in oil prices.

READ MORE: ‘Ticking time bomb:’ Alberta group wants aging oil wells to be election issue

“It is unfortunate that some have taken relief measures brought forward in order to keep people employed and politicized them in a time of crisis,” he said in an email.

The bill’s purpose is to help the province deal with more than 10,000 wells, well sites, pipeline segments and other facilities that haven’t been cleaned up by Alberta’s energy industry. The problem dates back decades, but has accelerated in recent years due to low oil prices.

The bill gives the group responsible for abandoned sites new powers.

The Orphan Well Association  will be able to enter private property to do reclamation work. It will also be able to take over abandoned wells and operate them.

READ MORE: Alberta needs better rules to ensure polluters clean up wells: Orphan Well Association

Bankes said some of those powers “fill a number of holes” in previous bills.

The association can now oversee land reclamation in addition to well clean-up, he said. Allowing it to operate facilities may be a public safety benefit in the case of, for example, toxic sour gas wells.

Story continues below advertisement

The bill also requires operators to take steps to prevent facilities from damage.

“It’s a step in the right direction,” Bankes said.

But the bill still contains no timelines for companies to clean things up, as is common in other jurisdictions, said Bankes. It also doesn’t do enough ensure companies have enough money to repair the damage they’ve done.

“We should actually be requiring wells that aren’t in production for a long period of time to be properly abandoned and the well site reclaimed,” he said.

“We’re not being proactive enough to demand security up front to cover liabilities.”

Dwight Popowich, who owns land in southern Alberta with energy facilities on it, said giving government officials more power to enter his property erodes his rights. He said allowing the Orphan Well Association to operate wells without making lease payments to landowners isn’t right.

“It’s not a lease any more, it’s forced expropriation.”

Boychuk said the bill also politicizes well clean-up by giving cabinet discretion over priorities. He also warns the bill will cost municipalities millions in unpaid property taxes when they are written off in bankruptcy.

Bal said the bill is one part of an overall package on the energy industry.

“This legislation is about protecting existing jobs and setting the stage for job creation during a time when it’s needed the most,” he wrote. “(It’s) part of larger package that includes a full suite of policies to address the issue of orphaned and abandoned wells.”

Olympics 2016

Olympics

Click above for more…