Study examines Alta. quakes, with suspected link to fracking

18 Nov 2016

Lethbridge Herald

THE CANADIAN PRESS — CALGARY

Research suggests hydraulic fracking can cause earthquakes in at least two ways — and one of them can cause tremors months after the activity stops.

“The seismicity is persistent after the operations are completed,” said David Eaton, a University of Calgary seismologist, whose paper has been published in the journal Science.

Eaton has been studying earthquakes that have shaken the Fox Creek region of northwestern Alberta for years.

The largest, measuring between 4.2 and 4.8 on the Richter scale, occurred in January. The area, which is in the centre of the Duvernay oil and gas field, has experienced hundreds of tremors since 2013.

Scientists have long known the shakers are associated with oilfield practices.

In the United States, underground waste-water disposal seems to be the cause. In Alberta, research points to hydraulic fracking, which involves pumping high-pressure fluids underground. That creates tiny cracks in rock and releases natural gas or oil held inside.

How the widely used technique creates earthquakes has largely remained a mystery — until now.

Eaton and his co-author Xuewei Bao used a mathematical algorithm to isolate and locate more than 900 earthquakes in the Fox Creek area.

“That gave us the ability to image the fault structure,” Eaton said. “We could see that there were steeply dipping faults that extended from the injection level down into the Precambrian basement.”

The pair also realized there were two hairline faults that hadn’t been spotted in previous work.

One fault, some distance from the fracking site, quaked as fluids were pumped down and stopped when the pumping did.

Eaton said those quakes were caused by stress changes on the rock from the pumping. When the pumping ended, the stress was reduced.

But the other fault, very close to the site, remained active for months.

The researchers combined their precise fault-mapping with equally precise data on how much fluid was pumped underground, when it was pumped and where.


 

Rural politicians boo Alta. climate-change plan

18 Nov 2016

Lethbridge Herald

THE CANADIAN PRESS — EDMONTON

The Alberta government got a bit of a rough ride at a meeting with rural politicians in Edmonton.

Deputy premier Sarah Hoffman was booed Thursday as she defended the NDP’s climatechange plan, which includes a carbon tax and a phase-out of coal-fired electricity.

Hoffman said it’s necessary to address climate change because the science behind it is real and there are serious health concerns tied to burning coal.

Hoffman and other cabinet ministers fielded questions from hundreds of delegates to the fall convention of the Alberta Association of Municipal Districts and Counties.

Premier Rachel Notley said in a speech that she understands concerns and debate is always healthy. But she told delegates that a robust climate-change plan gives Alberta more credibility as it fights for energy infrastructure such as pipelines.

“People are going to disagree sometimes, and we know that sometimes making hard decisions, particularly long-term decisions that bring about long-term repositioning and improvement for sometimes people who aren’t voters right now, that’s a little hard,” Notley said.


 

Protesters rally against carbon tax – Event draws crowd to Galt Gardens

6 Nov 2016

Lethbridge Herald

Tijana Martin

[email protected]

A few hundred displeased people gathered at Galt Gardens on Saturday as part of a province-wide rally. The event was predominately to oppose the Climate Leadership Implementation Act.

Herald photo by Tijana Martin A few hundred people gathered at Galt Gardens Saturday to participate in a province-wide rally, mainly against the upcoming carbon levy. @TMartinHerald.Dawn Deabis attended the event because she said she’s upset with Rachel Notley and the NDP government.

“We elected her because we needed a change, but we’re all pretty sorry for what we got,” said Deabis.

She said she hopes the government listens to those in attendance. “There’s too many people out of work, there’s going to be more people out of work, everything just needs to be better so I hope the government listens.”

On Friday, Environment Minster Shannon Phillips said the carbon tax will allow the province to invest in innovation and technology and create jobs for cleaner energy. “Keeping those good jobs right here in Alberta, and cleaning up our air and getting rid of dirty coal plants,” she said. “That’s what we are reinvesting that price on pollution in.”

“I don’t believe that,” said Deabis. “They can focus on energy but it’s the oil — we’re an oil province and there’s too many people out of work and we just need to not have the carbon tax,” said Deabis. “I think it will just cause more problems for more business, more people, more money out of my pocket — out of your pocket.”

“Bring back businesses into Alberta, we’ve seen them leave, we need them to come back. The government needs to promote business to stay, not to leave and I’m hoping that’s what they’ll do,” Deabis added.

Paul Hinman, former MLA for Cardston-Taber-Warner and original leader of the Wildrose party, was a speaker at the event as he covered for Grant Hunter who was home ill.

“I was in the legislature many times when Rachel talked about how she was going to be accountable, how she’d go and listen to the people and how we need to be representing the people,” said Hinman. “I think that if you actually went doorto-door and asked people, an overwhelming number of Albertans understand that this is just another big government push to tax people more or to tax industries and it’s a political agenda.”

A $20-per-tonne carbon levy will come into effect on Jan. 1. The levy targets more than 20 types of fuel which produce greenhouse gas emissions when combusted. The Alberta government states every penny raised through the levy will be reinvested into the province to reduce our carbon footprint by making investments in energy efficiency for homeowners and small business owners.

And most Albertans, approximately 66 per cent of households, will receive a full or partial rebate. Individuals who make $47,000 a year or less and couples or families who make under $95,000 will qualify for the rebate.

But Hinman doesn’t feel this is the time to implement a new levy.

“We’re an economic basket case — we’re struggling. Do not impose a tax, this is like having someone that’s weak and barely able to move and say ‘you know what, we need you to carry 10 more pounds and putting a weight on them,” said Hinman. “Our economy cannot handle a carbon tax right now.”

Hinman suggests postponing the levy or putting it to a plebiscite.

“If you really believe you have a mandate from Albertans, then show us that don’t believe that you do with a plebiscite.”

Those in attendance signed a petition which urged the Provincial Legislative Assembly to hold a referendum on the matter, but Hinman said the people must do more.

“The biggest message for people today is signing these petitions are great, but I’ve been in the house when Rachel herself has put many petitions to the table there presented to the government and government carries on,” said Hinman. “What we need to do is we need to start a movement of phoning, emailing and sending letters to the premier’s office, to Shannon Phillip’s office, to the energy minister’s office, finance minster’s office and absolutely bombarding them with an overwhelming number of people calling them and say ‘please postpone the carbon tax.’”

More information on the Climate Leadership Implementation Act can be found at www.finance.alberta.ca/ publica tions/tax_rebates/faqs_carbonlevy. Follow @TMartinHerald on Twitter


 

Opposition leader slams carbon tax – Brian Jean says it will make economy worse

6 Nov 2016

Lethbridge Herald

Rob Drinkwater THE CANADIAN PRESS— EDMONTON

Alberta’s Opposition leader told hundreds of people at a rally against a planned carbon tax that the province’s oil belongs to them. Brian Jean stressed that no one at Saturday’s rally at the legislature was blaming Notley for low energy prices that have hurt Alberta’s economy.

But Brian Jean says Notley’s carbon tax is going to make things worse.

Other rallies were held at the same time in other Alberta cities, and organizers circulated a petition calling for the government to hold a referendum on the carbon tax.

Tracy Leite, who spoke at the rally, said the business she and her husband started together has been forced to lay people off.

Leite says Notley wouldn’t understand unless she had to sit across from someone and tell them they were losing their job.

“Not every business owner is a highly-paid executive. I’m hanging on by a fingernail,” Leite told the crowd.

On Jan. 1, a new carbon tax kicks in, which will increase prices at the gas pumps and on heating bills. There will be full or partial rebates for lowand middle-income Albertans.

Environment Minister Shannon Phillips also introduced Bill 25 in the legislature Tuesday that, if passed, will forbid oilsands industries from collectively emitting more than 100 megatonnes of greenhouse gases a year. The bill is part of a multi-faceted plan being introduced in stages by Notley’s government to reduce the effects of climate change and to remake Alberta’s energy infrastructure into one that relies more on renewables such as wind, solar and hydro power.

Some people at the Edmonton rally questioned whether climate change was really a problem. Others acknowledged it, but said a carbon tax would only kick Alberta when it’s already down and wouldn’t stop carbon emitters like the U.S. and China.

Alicia Drader, a journeyman electrician who attended the rally, said green investment is a good thing, but said it won’t change things overnight. In the meantime, he said hasn’t worked since January and his EI benefits will run out in four weeks.

“It’s very stressing to not know what’s next, to now know what to do next.

“When you’ve exhausted sending out 200 resumes and you get a few phone calls and a handful of job interviews and then you end up having maybe 500 people going for two positions, it’s very challenging to get working,” Drader said.

“There’s a lot of people struggling.”

Jean told the crowd that Alberta’s oil is being “mishandled.”

He rejected Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s recent announcement that all provinces will need to set a baseline price for carbon by 2018, saying it’s potentially unconstitutional because it challenges the province’s right to manage its own natural resources.

“Our oil, our natural resources belong to us.

“They do not belong to Rachel Notley. They do not belong to Trudeau. They belong to the people of Alberta,” Jean told the crowd.


 

Stirling considering wind farm – ENVIRONMENT MINISTER OPTIMISTIC ABOUT POTENTIAL FROM PROPOSED PROJECT

7 Nov 2016

Lethbridge Herald

J.W. Schnarr
[email protected]

Following an open house at the end of October, the Village of Stirling is looking for ways the community can benefit from a large wind farm project currently being considered near the community.

During their regular meeting on Nov. 2, Stirling council discussed the results of an Oct. 26 open house on the proposed wind farm, and how the village could work with GreenGate Power.

“In my mind, it’s us being proactive,” said Mayor Ben Nilsson.

“I think there’s a great opportunity for us to do something here.”

Coun. Trevor Lewington said council could provide conditional support for the project and could use that support to encourage GreenGate to address issues put forward by area residents and to consider providing opportunities to the community.

Among the issues the village is looking to address is traffic management, environmental safety concerns, purchasing and procurement from local services, local employment opportunities, emergency response training and plans, and opportunities for ongoing social investment.

The project began development in 2007 and plans include about 17,000 acres of land located five kilometres northeast of Stirling on privately owned cultivated land.

The project will be about 133 megawatts in size and could begin construction in 2018. It could involve the construction of 46 wind turbines, an electrical collection system, access roads, and a new wind collector substation, called the Red Coat Substation.

On Friday, Environment Minister Shannon Phillips said there are more opportunities for municipalities to be part of large-scale energy projects.

“We’ve seen this approach from wind developers in particular, and other renewables developers ensuring community benefits,” she said. “Certainly around Vulcan and Carmangay, we’ve seen those kinds of arrangements. It’s great that the municipalities are looking at ways to ensure local employment and local economic benefits.”

She said she expects to see more of that growth in the future.

“Southern Alberta is the birthplace of Canadian wind energy industry,” she said. “We’ve already got many success stories of places that have raised their municipal tax base, and certainly benefitted from having that kind of energy in their communities.

“We have a number of advocates here in southern Alberta who are pleased to welcome that kind of opportunity.”

“I think, as we move forward with an expansion of renewables, there’s going to be more down here in southern Alberta, but more across the province as well,” she said. “We will find that there will be many more of these arrangements, whether it is local training, local hiring, or even some of the assembly and manufacturing opportunities.”


 

Economic growth key to decisions – SPENDING PROGRAMS MUST GROW ECONOMY: FINANCE MINISTER

4 Nov 2016

Lethbridge Herald

Jordan Press

THE CANADIAN PRESS — OTTAWA

Any new spending measures being pitched for the federal budget will have to demonstrate potential to help grow the economy if they expect to find favour with the Liberal government, Canada’s finance minister says.

In an interview with The Canadian Press, Bill Morneau said that as he crafts his second budget as finance minister, the economic-growth test is the first of multiple screens he is using to ensure debt levels don’t spiral out of control.

Too late, the opposition parties might jeer.

The Liberals used up a lot of their fiscal wiggle room this week with a fall economic update that included $32 billion in infrastructure spending over the next 11 years, accompanied by an equivalent amount of red ink on the federal books.

The document also warned the federal balance sheet would stay in the red even longer than the Liberals first promised — a total of $114.9 billion in deficits between 2016-17 and 2020-21, up from the $83.2 billion outlined in the last budget.

Nor have the Liberals said when they expect to see the budget back in balance, instead choosing to hold to a decidedly less sexy measure of ongoing fiscal prudence: the ratio of debt to gross domestic product.

In order for that figure to remain on a downward trajectory, the economy must grow at a faster rate than the debt, Morneau explained.

“That means that we’ve got to be thinking about all of our investment decisions in the context of how they enable us to grow the economy,” Morneau said. “That will be my screen as we think about Budget 2017 and beyond: How we can grow the economy and be fiscally prudent? Certainly it will present a challenge, but we believe that with this plan we can make a real impact on Canadian families.”

Building a budget involves complex tradeoffs between doing things that have to be done for short- and medium-term growth and those measures that may have to wait for another budget cycle, he added.

“Is there a way to do more with less? Is there a way to consider being more cost-effective against every initiative? That’s my ongoing approach to dealing with the things I’m hearing from Canadians and the things I’m hearing from my colleagues.”

In doubling down on an infrastructure program that was originally pegged at $60 billion over 10 years but now totals nearly $100 billion, the Liberals are hoping that program can spur growth and jobs, creating the tax base needed to help balance the budget.

Some of those changes won’t be felt right away — spending infrastructure money takes time and only leaves the federal treasury once project proponents submit receipts to show that work has progressed — and Morneau suggested that Canadians won’t see the effects of the long-term plan in the fiscal update for several years.

But the government believes its changes to tax rates for so-called middle-income earners, along with a new income-tested child benefit and short-term infrastructure spending, will create or maintain 100,000 jobs over the next two years, Morneau said — even though the parliamentary budget watchdog has cast doubt on the figure.


 

Carbon tax the best answer? – TAX WILL PLACE GREATER FINANCIAL BURDEN ON FAMILIES

4 Nov 2016

Lethbridge Herald

Rachael Harder

Canada was just ranked the top destination of the year by Lonely Planet’s 2017 travel guide. This ranking is based on Canada’s diversity. From the majestic beauty of the Niagara Falls, to the still beauty of Banff and Churchill, the old European architecture of Quebec City and Montreal, to the quaint fishermen’s community of Peggy’s Cove; Canada offers vibrancy, innovation and a warm welcome to all who visit.

Canada’s natural landscape and vast greenspace make our country unique. I am proud to be able to represent this beautiful nation. In order to maintain Canada’s beauty, however, we must be respectful towards the landscape we have. To preserve the elegance of Canada, maintenance of national parks and national historic sites is necessary.

Under our former Conservative government, we established climate targets for Canada. These targets would help us to preserve Canada’s natural beauty. Ironically, they were consistently attacked by the Liberals who have since adopted these same climate target goals. However, the Liberals have added something on top of them: a carbon tax.

A carbon tax places a price on greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions generated from burning fuel. It puts a price on each tonne of GHG emitted and is then taxed accordingly. Prime Minister Trudeau recently announced that the Liberal government would impose a “floor price” of $10 per tonne in 2018, rising to $50 a tonne by 2022.

The purpose of taxing these emissions is to increase the cost of using fossil fuels to encourage businesses and families to switch to alternative energy sources. This works better in theory than in reality. Imposing a carbon tax does not put a limit on the amount of emissions that can be released. A manufacturing company can continue releasing the same amount of emissions they do now; the only difference is that businesses will now be taxed for it — and those increased costs will be passed to you, the consumer, in the form of higher prices.

Provinces will not release fewer emissions than they did previously, as most people don’t have a choice if they drive a pickup truck or heat their home with natural gas. However, under the Liberal carbon tax, the residents of the province will have to somehow pay for it. Because of the carbon tax, every product you purchase and every household bill you pay will go up in cost.

To put this in perspective, in British Columbia there is a provincial carbon tax. This tax places a $30 per tonne price on carbon, adding 6.67 cents per litre at the gas pump. It makes B.C. the second most expensive province for gas prices in all of Canada, just behind Newfoundland and Labrador. In Alberta, if a carbon tax is fully implemented in 2018, gas prices will be roughly the same as in B.C. With the Liberal goal of $50 per tonne by 2022, gas prices will increase by at least 11 cents per litre.

A carbon tax will also mean significant increases to the price of heating your home. In Alberta, where we heat most of our houses using natural gas, under the carbon tax, there will be an increased tax of $1.50 a gigajoule. Although it may not seem significant at first, after one cold winter the difference will be alarming. It has been estimated that if this carbon tax is imposed on Canada, Alberta will be the most affected by the rise of electricity costs.

This increase in natural gas and electricity will also affect businesses, meaning the prices of non-energy products are also likely to increase. This, of course, directly affects households as they will be forced to spend more on everyday items like groceries and transportation.

Overall, it is estimated that with a $50 per tonne carbon tax, the average Canadian household will end up paying $600 per year. This amount will go up if you drive your own vehicle instead of taking public transit or if you own your own house instead of a condo. With the prices of everyday living already increasing, the carbon tax will have a detrimental impact on household budgets. With instability in the housing market and job loss on the rise, the last thing Canadians need from their government is another tax.

This carbon tax is the wrong approach to reaching climate targets and stimulating the economy. Forcing provinces to adopt a carbon tax is not in the best interest of Canadians — or Canada’s climate. Canadians will not stop purchasing groceries that were shipped to their local supermarket, quit heating their homes, or stop driving to work (especially in a place like Lethbridge). Therefore, carbon will still be released into the environment at the same rate it is now. The only difference the carbon tax will make is impose greater financial burden on families and kill jobs.

I know we are all tough Albertans who can brave the coldest of winters, but there does come a time when turning on the heat is nice. I for one do not want to pay extra tax for choosing not to be a human icicle, and as your Member of Parliament, I don’t think you should either.

white

PALLISER – 21 recommendations presented to board

4 Nov 2016

Lethbridge Herald

Follow @JWSchnarrHerald on Twitter

LETHBRIDGE HERALD

Citing a “culture and climate that is not psychologically healthy for employees,” an organizational review of Palliser Regional Schools has come back with 21 recommendations to improve the division.

Herald photo by Ian Martens Palliser Regional Schools board chair Robert Strauss, flanked by acting superintendent Garry Andrews and alternate vice-chair Craig Whitehead, speaks during a special meeting after the release of an organizational review Thursday at the division offices. @IMartensHeraldA special meeting held Thursday by the PRS Board of Trustees to hear the results of the review was attended by a full house of concerned parents and former employees of the division.

Robert Strauss, PRS board chair, said because the board received the recommendations at the same time the public did, it would now be looking deeper into the review in order to see where changes to the division could be made.

“The board is going to treat this report with the utmost seriousness,” he said. “We’ll spend the requisite amount of time to review the documents in great detail.”

The panel gathered information from stakeholders in the division that included a survey of the psychological safety climate within PRS; semistructured interviews with current and former employees, trustees and other stakeholders; documentary submissions from stakeholders; and data and documents requested from PRS. Recommendations included the division creating a plan to deal with aggression and fear in the workplace felt by many employees; clarifying the roles of the board and superintendent; identify and deal with a lack of trust of the board; the board must take ownership of the superintendent evaluation process; manage concerns with procedural fairness; develop a transparent conflict resolution process; improve communication at all levels of the division; develop an off-duty conduct policy; transparency in their electronic monitoring policy; develop a policy that clarifies when alcohol should and should not be purchased; and to develop a communications policy in order to keep the public informed.

As the full review is more than 200 pages long, Strauss could not give a timeline on any decisions that might come out of it.

“We will take as much time as we need to do a thorough job and do it right,” he said, adding it would be unlikely the review would be dealt with in the next board meeting.

“During the course of upcoming weeks and months, we’ll have an opportunity to address this report.”

He said the division has many positive traits, and the board will look at the recommendations as an opportunity to improve areas that are lacking.

“We also heard today this division has a lot of positives in it,” he said. “We have a lot of things we need to look at for improvement. And we welcome that challenge.”

Strauss described the division as a partnership between staff, parents and students, and said the board welcomes the opportunity to work with those groups.

“I was very appreciative for the interest that the parents and the public have shown,” he said.

“This is part of our commitment to work with the people in our system, and to work with the public to create a better system. It’s my intent to work with the stakeholders to ensure we do get better.”

The executive summary is available online at pallisersd.ab.ca.


Area MLA hearing plenty of concerns

16 Oct 2016

Lethbridge Herald

STEPHANIE LABBE — SOUTHERN ALBERTA NEWSPAPERS

GRANT HUNTER STAGED NUMEROUS MEETINGS

Grant Hunter, MLA for Cardston-Taber-Warner, has been hearing the concerns from his constituents.

Wildrose MLA Hunter held meetings at the beginning of September in Cardston, Warner, Milk River, Coutts, Magrath and Raymond to hear what the public’s concerns are, so he can bring them to the Legislature.

The meetings went well, says Hunter and he was interested to hear the different concerns of the people.

A lot of people were asking him questions about the carbon tax, the implications of increasing minimum wage and how it’s going to affect their businesses.

As well, some of the seniors were asking about the new Seniors Home Adaptation and Repair Program (SHARP).

“It was actually … very good to be able to meet with the constituents and get some feedback on them from what they feel is going on,” adds Hunter.

Hunter says he likes to hold these meetings in most of the different communities within his constituency every six to eight months or so.

He wants to keep up to date with what the people in his constituency want to see happen as well as their specific concerns.

When it comes to the SHARP program, Hunter says he talks to the seniors about how they can qualify for that and if they might qualify and he talks to the seniors about the program and its benefits.

He adds probably nine out of 10 people he spoke with said the Wildrose and Progressive Conservatives should unite, so Hunter says it is interesting that high of a number of people said they need to get together with the PC party.

At some of the meetings there were only a couple of people while others had better attendance. All of the meetings were done on a drop-in basis.

This month, Hunter says they are going back to the Legislature to discuss the revisions to the Municipal Government Act coming out, which is Bill 21.

“We’ve heard some good information from the reeves and mayors … at the reeves and mayors meeting that we have and so they’ve given us … ideas about maybe some amendments that should be brought forward,” he adds.


 

Prentice a great politician and family man

15 Oct 2016

Lethbridge Herald

Dave Mabell [email protected]

Shocked by his sudden death, political leaders spoke out Friday in tribute to former Alberta premier Jim Prentice. Retired from politics since the Progressive Conservatives lost power in May 2015, Prentice was one of four people killed when a small aircraft crashed Thursday near Kelowna.

“For Alberta, today is a day of sorrow in the face of terrible tragedy,” said Premier Rachel Notley.

“He served our province in so many roles for so many years. He deeply loved Alberta. He worked tirelessly for all of us, in the true spirit of one who is committed to public service,” she said.

“I benefited from his advice, and the government of Alberta is continuing to pursue many of his initiatives. All Albertans are the better for this.” Shannon Phillips, MLA for Lethbridge West, paid tribute to Prentice’s work on environmental issues while serving in the federal cabinet.

“I did not know him personally, but I see the echoes of his work on the environment,” she said, particularly with regard to oilsands monitoring.

As a Calgary MP, Prentice filled several roles in Stephen Harper’s federal cabinet including minister of the environment.

Phillips, now Alberta’s environment minister, said she’s learned more about his efforts from other government officials who worked with him.

The minister was scheduled to address members of the Lethbridge Chamber of Commerce during their “Opportunity South” conference Friday. Out of respect, Notley and her cabinet members cancelled appearances for the day.

Lethbridge East MLA Maria Fitzpatrick praised Prentice’s spirit of public service.

“Anyone who has put themself out for public service the way Mr. Prentice did deserves every accolade anyone can give,” she said. “He served both his province and Canada well.”

Mayor Chris Spearman voiced city council’s sorrow at the former premier’s death.

“The sudden passing of Mr. Prentice is a shocking and tragic loss,” he said. “My heart goes out to his wife Karen and the entire Prentice family.

“Mr. Prentice was a dedicated public servant who enriched our province with his leadership and passion.”

The mayor ordered flags be lowered to half-mast at city hall and other civic locations.

Former Lethbridge East MLA and city council member Bridget Pastoor praised Prentice’s contributions as the nation’s aboriginal affairs minister.

“The work he did with First Nations was exemplary,” she said. “His heart was in it, and he knew what he was doing.”

Prentice was a political leader with integrity, Pastoor said, and “You probably couldn’t find a nicer gentleman.

“He served Canada very well, and devoted his life to public service.”

Greg Weadick, MLA for Lethbridge West and a cabinet minister under several Progressive Conservative premiers, described Prentice as “very hard-working MP, MLA and premier.”

Part of that work, he said, was finding ways to support First Nations in southern Alberta and elsewhere in their economic development initiatives. When Prentice served as environment minister, Weadick added, he attempted to balance the needs to safeguard Canada’s environmental values while recognizing the importance of resource-based employment.

At the same time, Weadick said, Prentice was “very dedicated to his wife and family.”

Follow @DMabellHerald on Twitter